The Marshal

Nestled in the vibrant heart of New York City’s Theater District, The Marshal offers an inviting and lively American dining experience with a distinctive pizza restaurant twist. Located at 628 10th Ave, this neighborhood gem expertly marries locally sourced ingredients with inventive wood-fired cooking, delivering a menu that thrills both traditionalists and culinary adventurers alike.

The Marshal’s culinary canvas features standout dishes that truly captivate the palate. The Smoked Hudson Valley Duck Breast Pizza offers a sublime play of smoky richness layered over a perfectly blistered crust, while their Truffle & Porcini Mushroom Pizza envelops you in earthy elegance, each bite punctuated by the deep, woodsy aromas of forest mushrooms and truffle oil. For seafood lovers, the Shrimp Scampi Pizza delivers a vibrant, garlicky freshness balanced with tender shrimp, making it a uniquely satisfying slice unlike any other.

But The Marshal’s appeal extends beyond pizzas. Their Famous Wood Fired Meatloaf is a comforting yet elevated take on a classic, boasting a charred exterior and juicy interior that lingers in your memory. Equally enticing are the Wood Oven Roasted Chicken Wings, crispy and succulent with a subtle smoky backbone. The Apple & Sunchoke Salad balances bright tartness with nutty richness, adding a refreshing contrast to the heartier plates.

The atmosphere here pulses with a warm, bustling energy that reflects its prime Midtown location—perfect for a casual dinner before a Broadway show or a lively night out with friends. Waitstaff are attentive and friendly, often going the extra mile to accommodate special requests, as one guest delighted in having duck prosciutto served on the side for a vegetarian at their table. Another enjoyed a custom cocktail, praising the mixologist’s skill in crafting a flawless Bees Knees.

Beverages at The Marshal are thoughtfully curated. Craft beer enthusiasts will appreciate selections like the crisp Pale Ale from Bronx Brewery or the smooth Kill Van Kolsch by Flagship Brewing Co.. The wine list thoughtfully complements the menu, while coffee and tea offerings—such as the rich Brazilian dark roast and a variety of expertly blended teas—round out the experience.

The dessert offerings are equally memorable; the rich, fudgy Chocolate Brownie and complimentary treats gifted to guests after an unexpected mishap reflect The Marshal’s genuine hospitality and desire to turn every meal into a lasting memory.

While some diners have noted that the lively space can get noisy during peak hours, the friendly and accommodating staff continually make each visit worthwhile. Whether you’re savoring the velvety deviled eggs, delighting in the innovative pizza toppings, or unwinding with expertly crafted cocktails, The Marshal consistently delivers a deeply satisfying and authentic New York dining experience that invites you to return again and again.